We're honored to live and work in the community we serve.


Providing local expertise and the power of choice is the Brightway difference.

Welcome to Brightway, The Fernandina Beach Agency

Talk to an Agent icon New to us? Talk to an Agent 904-491-7622

Current policy Holder Icon Current Policyholder? 888-254-5014

Shining Sun A more personal way to shop insurance.


Here at Brightway, The Fernandina Beach Agency we work hard to provide the best insurance-buying experience and service available. For us, that means being trusted industry experts in the community and providing you with the most choice in insurance companies. 

Our team is led by Michael Tarzia, an agent with more than seven years of experience in the industry and a resident of Nassau County. As an agency, we take the time to develop a relationship with you so we really understand your needs. If we can answer any questions about Home, Auto, Life, Business or other types of insurance, stop by or give us a call.  

 

Shining Sun Providing our customers with high levels of service.

Michael Tarzia
Michael Tarzia Agency Owner

A resident of Nassau County for over 10 years, Michael has spent most of that time as part of the Brightway family. He began his insurance career after graduating from West Virginia University. 

Michael is a strong supporter of Fernandina Beach and Yulee sports programs and a proud sponsor of the Fernandina Beach little league teams. He also supports local charities, including Micah's Place and the Boys and Girls Club in Yulee. 

Michael is married with two small children. He is dedicated to his family, friends and community and is committed to doing everything he can to contribute to the community his family calls home.

  • Michael Tarzia
    Michael Tarzia Agency Owner

    A resident of Nassau County for over 10 years, Michael has spent most of that time as part of the Brightway family. He began his insurance career after graduating from West Virginia University. 

    Michael is a strong supporter of Fernandina Beach and Yulee sports programs and a proud sponsor of the Fernandina Beach little league teams. He also supports local charities, including Micah's Place and the Boys and Girls Club in Yulee. 

    Michael is married with two small children. He is dedicated to his family, friends and community and is committed to doing everything he can to contribute to the community his family calls home.

    Michael Tarzia Agency Owner
    Michael Tarzia
    Michael Tarzia Agency Owner

    A resident of Nassau County for over 10 years, Michael has spent most of that time as part of the Brightway family. He began his insurance career after graduating from West Virginia University. 

    Michael is a strong supporter of Fernandina Beach and Yulee sports programs and a proud sponsor of the Fernandina Beach little league teams. He also supports local charities, including Micah's Place and the Boys and Girls Club in Yulee. 

    Michael is married with two small children. He is dedicated to his family, friends and community and is committed to doing everything he can to contribute to the community his family calls home.

  • Timothy  Yarbrough
    Timothy Yarbrough Insurance Agent

    Timothy is committed to helping customers find the insurance they need at a price they can afford. Since joining our office, he has been focused on helping friends and neighbors find the coverages they need to protect their assets. His reward for a great job is his sales performance as he is working toward becoming a top producer in the Brightway system.

    Timothy Yarbrough Insurance Agent
    Timothy  Yarbrough
    Timothy Yarbrough Insurance Agent

    Timothy is committed to helping customers find the insurance they need at a price they can afford. Since joining our office, he has been focused on helping friends and neighbors find the coverages they need to protect their assets. His reward for a great job is his sales performance as he is working toward becoming a top producer in the Brightway system.

  • Angela  Pruitt
    Angela Pruitt Insurance Agent

    Angela is an invaluable resource in the agency. She presses her 14 years of insurance experience into service every day as she helps people find the right coverages and policies.  Adding to her expertise, Angela has been a resident of Nassau County for more than 36 years, so she has expertise in understanding the area and its residents’ unique insurance needs. 

    Angela Pruitt Insurance Agent
    Angela  Pruitt
    Angela Pruitt Insurance Agent

    Angela is an invaluable resource in the agency. She presses her 14 years of insurance experience into service every day as she helps people find the right coverages and policies.  Adding to her expertise, Angela has been a resident of Nassau County for more than 36 years, so she has expertise in understanding the area and its residents’ unique insurance needs. 

Yellow Sun Shine More choice. More convenience. More confidence.


Yellow Sun Shine Visit us today.


Give us a Call
904-491-7622
Our Office

960185 Gateway Blvd Unit 107
Fernandina Beach, FL 32034

Get Directions >
Hours of Operation

Monday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Tuesday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Wednesday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Thursday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Friday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Saturday: By Appointment Only
Sunday: Closed

Let us find the right insurance for you.


Reach out and we’ll get back to you with a custom policy that fits your unique situation.