We're honored to live and work in the community we serve.


Providing local expertise and the power of choice is the Brightway difference.

Welcome to Brightway, Fleming Island

Talk to an Agent icon New to us? Talk to an Agent 904-278-7749

Current policy Holder Icon Current Policyholder? 888-254-5014

Shining Sun A more personal way to shop insurance.


When it comes to buying insurance, Brightway, Fleming Island, is your source for more choices and better service. Whether you’re looking for a competitive rate for Homeowners insurance or need help determining the right amount of auto coverage, you’ll receive personal attention from industry experts committed to your satisfaction. If we can answer any questions about Home, Auto, Flood or other types of insurance, stop by or give us a call. 

Shining Sun Providing our customers with high levels of service.

David Leinecker
David Leinecker Agency Owner

Born and raised in Miami, David lived in Fort Lauderdale and Sebring before moving to North Florida in 2000. Licensed in insurance since 1988, he’s held positions in Claims and Sales at Allstate, State Farm, Prudential and Humana prior to becoming a Brightway Agency Owner. 

David earned his B.S. in Business Administration from the University of Florida and his M.B.A. from Florida International University. He also holds the Chartered Advisor for Senior Living, Chartered Life Underwriter, and Chartered Financial Consultant designations from The American College. 

David lives in Eagle Harbor with his three children and his dog Lucy. He is an usher at Hibernia Baptist Church and was involved with Boy Scouts for 12 years.

  • David Leinecker
    David Leinecker Agency Owner

    Born and raised in Miami, David lived in Fort Lauderdale and Sebring before moving to North Florida in 2000. Licensed in insurance since 1988, he’s held positions in Claims and Sales at Allstate, State Farm, Prudential and Humana prior to becoming a Brightway Agency Owner. 

    David earned his B.S. in Business Administration from the University of Florida and his M.B.A. from Florida International University. He also holds the Chartered Advisor for Senior Living, Chartered Life Underwriter, and Chartered Financial Consultant designations from The American College. 

    David lives in Eagle Harbor with his three children and his dog Lucy. He is an usher at Hibernia Baptist Church and was involved with Boy Scouts for 12 years.

    David Leinecker Agency Owner
    David Leinecker
    David Leinecker Agency Owner

    Born and raised in Miami, David lived in Fort Lauderdale and Sebring before moving to North Florida in 2000. Licensed in insurance since 1988, he’s held positions in Claims and Sales at Allstate, State Farm, Prudential and Humana prior to becoming a Brightway Agency Owner. 

    David earned his B.S. in Business Administration from the University of Florida and his M.B.A. from Florida International University. He also holds the Chartered Advisor for Senior Living, Chartered Life Underwriter, and Chartered Financial Consultant designations from The American College. 

    David lives in Eagle Harbor with his three children and his dog Lucy. He is an usher at Hibernia Baptist Church and was involved with Boy Scouts for 12 years.

  • Estelle  Sanderlin
    Estelle Sanderlin Agency Principle

    Estelle was born and raised in Montpelier, Vermont, and has been working in the insurance industry for more than nine years. As a General Lines Agent, she is able to write both Personal and Commercial Lines in the state of Florida. She also holds a Life insurance license. Estelle lives in Middleburg with her husband, two children, dogs and a cat.

    Estelle Sanderlin Agency Principle
    Estelle  Sanderlin
    Estelle Sanderlin Agency Principle

    Estelle was born and raised in Montpelier, Vermont, and has been working in the insurance industry for more than nine years. As a General Lines Agent, she is able to write both Personal and Commercial Lines in the state of Florida. She also holds a Life insurance license. Estelle lives in Middleburg with her husband, two children, dogs and a cat.

Yellow Sun Shine Our reputation says it all.


  • This had to be the best service I have ever received from an insurance broker and I had no complaints with the one we had in Maryland, but David and Melanie are exceptional. Start to finish, Brightway, David and Melanie are amazing...professional, accurate, responsive and found us a great deal in a tough market. Kudos to Brightway. 

    Donna P. 

  • David provided several estimates and scenarios to provide best options for my situation. He kept in contact without being intrusive. Educated me on questions I had on how to bring down rate and still be protected. Dealt with David, professional and responsive. Would recommend and wished more Angie’s List users provided feedback on this type service.

    Tim W. 

  • I was just looking for an Auto insurance quote and ended up switching. I had heard that Mr. Leinecker could offer much better rates than many other companies, so I asked him for a quote. He was able to save me about $400/year on Auto insurance. The staff was very friendly and personable and did a great job.

    Stephanie B. 

  • I just wanted to drop you a line and let you know that Madonna did a great job on following up with my request. In fact, I had forgotten about some forms I needed to sign, and she called to remind me. Thank you.

    Sarah K.

  • Monique is very helpful and professional and always goes above and beyond. She remembered my name and information without asking me the same questions over and over. You are very lucky to employ such a great professional like Monique!

    Oleg B.

  • I spoke with Kimberly today about some help I needed on my Auto insurance policy. I was impressed how she went the extra mile to help me out before I even asked. I was very pleased and would like to praise her for her great job performance. Please pass it along.

    Jason D.

  • I wanted to let you know that recently I had to initiate a number of changes and revisions to my home policy. Through this entire process, Marianne has been extremely helpful. In addition to having a great personality, she did the one thing customers most appreciate - she kept me informed! It was a pleasure working with her; I will recommend Brightway to my associates.

    Ron B.

  • Clayton went above and beyond on our call, answering questions about my flood insurance when I originally called with a questions about my auto insurance. His follow-up email later in the day was icing on the cake!

    Daryll

  • Matt is a true professional and managed to handle a difficult problem with ease. He took the extra steps to follow up and make sure all was well. Thanks and pat Matt on the back for us. — Well done.

    Randy and Linda

Yellow Sun Shine More choice. More convenience. More confidence.


Yellow Sun Shine Visit us today.


Give us a Call
904-278-7749
Our Office

5000 US Highway 17 Suite 14
Fleming Island, FL 32003

Get Directions >
Hours of Operation

Monday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Tuesday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Wednesday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Thursday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Friday: 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Saturday: By Appointment Only
Sunday: Closed

Let us find the right insurance for you.


Reach out and we’ll get back to you with a custom policy that fits your unique situation.

255 Characters Remaining