We're honored to live and work in the community we serve.


Providing local expertise and the power of choice is the Brightway difference.

Welcome to Brightway, The Casey Agency

Talk to an Agent icon New to us? Talk to an Agent 904-217-7547

Current policy Holder Icon Current Policyholder? 888-254-5014

Shining Sun A more personal way to shop insurance.


Discover a better insurance-buying experience with Brightway, The Casey Agency. Our trusted industry experts combine access to an unparalleled number of insurance companies and policies with personalized attention and service that’s second to none. We specialize in handling complex property insurance issues with a focus on navigating the many changes in Flood insurance. As a team, we believe that developing a relationship with you helps us understand your needs and provide superior service. 

If we can answer any questions about Home, Auto, Business, Life or other types of insurance, stop by or give us a call.

Shining Sun Providing our customers with high levels of service.

Ashley Casey
Ashley Casey Agency Owner

A Florida native, Ashley has lived in St. Augustine for over 27 years. He began his career as a Catastrophe Claim Adjuster with the nation’s largest Homeowners insurance carrier which has given him valuable experience that he puts to work helping customers ensure they are properly protected. 

Ashley serves his community as a Rotarian and member of the Chamber of Commerce.  He is a graduate of Leadership St. Johns and the University of North Florida, and works with the United Way of St. Johns County.

  • Ashley Casey
    Ashley Casey Agency Owner

    A Florida native, Ashley has lived in St. Augustine for over 27 years. He began his career as a Catastrophe Claim Adjuster with the nation’s largest Homeowners insurance carrier which has given him valuable experience that he puts to work helping customers ensure they are properly protected. 

    Ashley serves his community as a Rotarian and member of the Chamber of Commerce.  He is a graduate of Leadership St. Johns and the University of North Florida, and works with the United Way of St. Johns County.

    Ashley Casey Agency Owner
    Ashley Casey
    Ashley Casey Agency Owner

    A Florida native, Ashley has lived in St. Augustine for over 27 years. He began his career as a Catastrophe Claim Adjuster with the nation’s largest Homeowners insurance carrier which has given him valuable experience that he puts to work helping customers ensure they are properly protected. 

    Ashley serves his community as a Rotarian and member of the Chamber of Commerce.  He is a graduate of Leadership St. Johns and the University of North Florida, and works with the United Way of St. Johns County.

Yellow Sun Shine More choice. More convenience. More confidence.


Yellow Sun Shine Visit us today.


Give us a Call
904-217-7547
Our Office

108 Sea Grove Main Street, Suite B
St. Augustine, FL 32080

Get Directions >
Hours of Operation

Monday: 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday: 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Wednesday: 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Thursday: 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Friday: 9 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Saturday: By Appointment Only
Sunday: Closed

Let us find the right insurance for you.


Reach out and we’ll get back to you with a custom policy that fits your unique situation.

255 Characters Remaining