We're honored to live and work in the community we serve.


Providing local expertise and the power of choice is the Brightway difference.

Welcome to Brightway, The Starkey Agency

Talk to an Agent icon New to us? Talk to an Agent 321-280-5500

Current policy Holder Icon Current Policyholder? 888-254-5014

Shining Sun A more personal way to shop insurance.


Here at Brightway, The Starkey Agency we offer the best insurance-buying experience available. For us, that means being the trusted industry experts in your neighborhood and providing more choices of insurance companies and policy options. 

Our team is led by Craig Starkey, an agent with extensive experience with rental properties and their owners. As a team, we believe that developing relationships is the best way to understand your needs and provide the personalized attention you deserve. 

If we can answer any questions about Home, Auto, Business or other types of insurance, stop by or give us a call. 

Shining Sun Providing our customers with high levels of service.

Craig Starkey
Craig Starkey Agency Owner

Craig has lived in the Winter Park-Maitland area for over 35 years and has 35 years of experience in finance, construction and insurance. He is active in the Maitland Rotary Club which assists both local and international charities.

Craig has three sons and enjoys spending time with his family. He attended Rollins College for his undergraduate degree and also received his M.B.A. from the Crummer School of Business at Rollins College. 

Craig is an active member of the Winter Park Racquet Club and enjoys playing tennis in his spare time. 

  • Craig Starkey
    Craig Starkey Agency Owner

    Craig has lived in the Winter Park-Maitland area for over 35 years and has 35 years of experience in finance, construction and insurance. He is active in the Maitland Rotary Club which assists both local and international charities.

    Craig has three sons and enjoys spending time with his family. He attended Rollins College for his undergraduate degree and also received his M.B.A. from the Crummer School of Business at Rollins College. 

    Craig is an active member of the Winter Park Racquet Club and enjoys playing tennis in his spare time. 

    Craig Starkey Agency Owner
    Craig Starkey
    Craig Starkey Agency Owner

    Craig has lived in the Winter Park-Maitland area for over 35 years and has 35 years of experience in finance, construction and insurance. He is active in the Maitland Rotary Club which assists both local and international charities.

    Craig has three sons and enjoys spending time with his family. He attended Rollins College for his undergraduate degree and also received his M.B.A. from the Crummer School of Business at Rollins College. 

    Craig is an active member of the Winter Park Racquet Club and enjoys playing tennis in his spare time. 

  • Tom  Hubbard
    Tom Hubbard Senior Producing Agent

    An Agent with Brightway, The Starkey Agency since the beginning, Tom enjoys building deep relationships with customers which helps him customize insurance solutions that uniquely fit their needs.

    Tom Hubbard Senior Producing Agent
    Tom  Hubbard
    Tom Hubbard Senior Producing Agent

    An Agent with Brightway, The Starkey Agency since the beginning, Tom enjoys building deep relationships with customers which helps him customize insurance solutions that uniquely fit their needs.

Yellow Sun Shine More choice. More convenience. More confidence.


Yellow Sun Shine Visit us today.


Give us a Call
321-280-5500
Our Office

2335 Temple Trail Suite 5
Winter Park, FL 32789

Get Directions >
Hours of Operation

Monday: 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Tuesday: 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Wednesday: 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Thursday: 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Friday: 8 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.
Saturday: By Appointment Only
Sunday: Closed

Let us find the right insurance for you.


Reach out and we’ll get back to you with a custom policy that fits your unique situation.